Showing posts with label plagiarism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label plagiarism. Show all posts

Sunday, May 1, 2011

Where Do Students Plagiarize from the Most?

I just found a list of websites that inform most of the student cheating. It's almost enough to make you lose faith in the younger generation to see where students mostly plagiarize from: 
Over all, the top eight sites for matched content were Wikipedia, Yahoo Answers, Answers.com, SlideShare, OPPapers.com, Scribd, Course Hero, and MedLibrary.org
 If they think that Wikipedia and Yahoo Answers are legitimate sources of information for college essays, this means we have been able to teach them nothing. Of course, if instead of churning out more idiotic paperwork, our bureaucrats occupied themselves with punishing plagiarism, the problem could be eradicated pretty fast.

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

There Is Plagiarism And Then There Is Stupid Plagiarism

When I was giving my lecture on Goytisolo, I informed students that he is my favorite writer ever and that I have published articles on his work. The most recent of these articles is scheduled to come out next month. I told them that I can't stop reading his Marks of Identity and Count Julian because every new reading brings something new to my understanding of his work. When answering questions about Goytisolo, I demonstrated an extensive knowledge of his writing.

So, please, tell me, what kind of a genius then goes and inserts sentences copied directly from Goytisolo's second most famous novel Marks of Identity into their own text without putting them into quotation marks and attributing them to the source? Is there any chance that I will not be able to distinguish a student's writing from that of one of the most important Spanish authors of the XXth century? What is the likelihood of me not recognizing Goytisolo's very distinctive second person narrator?

And most importantly, what's the point of alienating the professor in this way during the penultimate week of the semester?

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Conversation with a Plagiarizing Student

Student: I don't understand why I got a zero for the final essay. It says here I plagiarized. That's so unfair. I worked very hard on this. You can ask my mother if you don't believe me.

Me: This entire part of your essay was copy-pasted from a website.

Student (raising her voice): What??? I never copy-pasted anything from any website. I wrote that myself. You can ask my mother who saw me work on the essay all night long.

Me: So you are telling me this is not copy-pasted from a website?

Student (almost yelling): I would never! Of course, not!!

Me: OK, let's enter this passage into Google Search. Oh, look what I found. Here is your passage verbatim on this website.

Student (starting to cry): Well, but the rest of the essay is good. I worked all night long. I don't deserve a bad grade for this.

Me: So you recognize that you plagiarized?

Student (sobbing and waving hands in my face): I never plagiarize!! You can ask my mother! She will tell you how hard I worked on this essay.

Me: Did we not just find this very text on a website?

Student: So? I worked hard! My mother. . .

Me: Copy-pasting from a website is not plagiarism?

Student (shrieking): I hate this course! I didn't understand anything you ever said in class. And I didn't understand any of the readings either.

Me: I'm surprised that I'm only hearing this now, on the last day of classes. Why did you never come to my ofiice hours, asked any questions in class, or emailed me to share your difficulties with the course?

Student (yelling at the top of her lungs at this point): Because what's the point if you are going to accuse me of plagiarism anyways? Why are you yelling at me anyways?

Me: What do you mean "accuse"? Didn't we just discover this entire passage verbatim on a website?

Student: This is so wrong! I worked hard!!!! Just ask my mother!

After which the student storms out of my office. My blood pressure goes through the roof and my hands are shaking. A colleague passing by sees me, looks scared, and asks if I need to be driven to the hospital. I later see the cheating student in the hallway complaining to other professors that bad, mean, horrible me dared to fail her for being a plagiarist.

Wednesday, December 8, 2010

Plagiarism

I spent the entire day yesterday grading long final essays in one of my courses. Throughout the semester, there were several instances of plagiarism, so I had to give a number of talks on what constitutes plagiarism and why it is wrong. I asked students to avoid using the Internet for any purpose whatsoever while they are writing the essay. Apparently, that didn't work because six of my 35 students handed in plagiarized papers. When I say that they plagiarized, I mean that they copy-pasted some stuff they found on-line into the essays, without, of course, attributing these stolen parts to any source. The saddest thing is that 3 of them plagiarized the same rubbish from the same racist, lying anti-immigration website. Imagine how it feels to keep encountering the same idiotic passage word-for-word in three different essays.

My policy on plagiarism, as I explained to students on numerous occasions, is that the moment I see a plagiarized sentence, I stop reading the essay and give a zero for the entire assignment. The problem with plagiarism is that - as much as we try to conceal it from the students - the college system is not designed to punish plagiarists. When I was teaching my first college-level class, I was still fresh out of my undergraduate studies. So I honestly believed the entire "this-university-takes-plagiarism-very-seriously" spiel we had been regularly offered as students. The moment I caught somebody cheating on the very first test I administered, I took the test away from the cheating student and sent her to the administration to be punished accordingly. Nothing much happened, and two weeks later I caught the same student cheating once again. This time, I took her to the administration personally. And that was when I discovered that college administrators don't want to know about cases of student plagiarism. Teachers who try to bring cheating to the attention of the authorities are considered trouble-makers and treated like tiresome fusspots.

A corporate university is only interested in the number of bodies it can sign up and charge tuition. The quality of those bodies, as well as what they do in the classroom and in their assignments, is of secondary (if that) interest. As a result, as much as I threaten the cheaters that I will inform the administration of their plagiarism, I know well enough that I'm not likely to do that. Many professors even feel obligated to reward plagiarists by offering them an opportunity to redo the assignment. This gives cheaters an extension that we normally eny to our good, honest students

There are many things that can be done to reduce plagiarism on campus. I would propose a university-wide database of cheaters. Every time a student is caught plagiarizing, they would be entered by the professor - bypassing the useless administrators altogether - into the system. When a student cheats for the third time, they should be automatically expelled. I have no doubt that after a few well-publicized expulsions, the number of plagiarized assignments would drop dramatically. Of course, this would only work if administrators were excluded from the process. Obviously, that is not likely to happen, and student cheating will keep flourishing.

P.S. Just discovered a student who plagiarized from the textbook we are using in this course. Of all the stupid things to do, inserting entire paragraphs from the textbook that the professor obviously knows by heart is truly the winner of the stupidity prize this semester.

Friday, March 5, 2010

Student Cheating: Any Suggestions?

Fellow educators and pedagogues: do you have any suggestions on how to deal with the following situation? My students were writing a mid-term yesterday. After the exam, one of my students (who is also my most brilliant student) told me that another student cheated. Apparently, she had notes on her Ipod and kept consulting them. I looked at the exam and I believe that the student in question was, in fact, cheating. She is a very weak student and her answers to the questions were way too perfect.

Of course, I felt angry and disgusted. I even had nightmares because cheating and plagiarism always traumatize me too much.

So the question is: what should I do about the cheating student? I haven't caught her in the process because I always trust students not to do these things. But I don't think it's right simply to let it go and give her 100% for an exam she wrote by cheating.

Any suggestions?